BASEBALL
2015
D3baseball.com Preseason All-American: George Lund
2014
D3baseball.com All-American Second Team: Tyler Pogmore
ABCA Division III All-American Third Team: George Lund
D3baseball.com All-American Honorable Mention: George Lund
WOMEN’S BASKETBALL
2013-14
WBCA All-American Honorable Mention: Kaitlyn Bovee
WOMEN’S CROSS COUNTRY
2013
NCAA Division III All-American: Hannah Zydanowicz
MEN’S CROSS COUNTRY
2025
NCAA Division III Men's Cross Country All-American: Nathan Tassey
2024
NCAA Division III Men's Cross Country All-American: Nathan Tassey
2023
NCAA Division III Men's Cross Country All-American: Nathan Tassey
EQUESTRIAN
2016-17
Kaia Lindberg – IHSA All-American in Walk-Trot-Canter Equitation
FIELD HOCKEY
2025
NFHCA NCAA Division III All-American Second Team: Chelsea King
MEN’S ICE HOCKEY
1983-84
NAIA All-American Team: John Bessette
WOMEN’S LACROSSE
2026
USA Lacrosse Division III All-American Honorable Mention: Miranda Hayes
2025
USA Lacrosse Division III All-American Honorable Mention: Miranda Hayes
2023
IWLCA Third Team All-American: Ryleigh Cavanaugh
MEN’S LACROSSE
2026
USA Lacrosse Division III All-American Honorable Mention: Kyle Zirn
USILA Division III All-American Honorable Mention:Kyle Zirn
2025
USA Lacrosse Division III All-American Honorable Mention: Kyle Zirn
2021
USILA Division III All-American Honorable Mention: Connor Hillemeir, Peter Navarro
2015
USILA Division III All-American Honorable Mention: Mark Fesenmeyer
SAILING
2024-25
ICSA All-American Women’s Skipper: Lucy Meagher
ICSA All-American Open Skipper Honorable Mention: Carlos Bermudez de Castro
ICSA All-American Women’s Crew Honorable Mention: Maren Matthews
ICSA All-American Open Crew Honorable Mention: Carly Kiss
2023-24
ICSA All-American Open Crew: Carly Kiss
ICSA All-American Open Skipper Honorable Mention: Carlos Bermudez de Castro, Aidan Hoogland, Kyle Pfrang
ICSA All-American Open Crew Honorable Mention: Claire Buckley, Michaela O’Donnell
2022-23
ICSA All-American Crew Honorable Mention: Molly Matthews
2020-21
Emily Gildea: ICSA All-American Coed Crew
Rachel Holick: ICSA All-America Honorable Mention Crew
Cameron Wood: ICSA All-America Honorable Mention Coed Skipper
2018-19
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Jennifer Agell
ICSA All-America Honorable Mention Coed Skipper: Conner Harding
2017-18
ICSA All-American Coed Skipper: Martim Anderson
ICSA All-American Coed Skipper: Mackenzie Bryan
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Jennifer Agell
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Rebecca Anderson
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Michael McBrien
2016-17
ICSA All-American Honorable Mention Coed Skipper: Mackenzie Bryan
ICSA All-American Honorable Mention Coed Crew: Jennifer Agell
2015-16
ICSA All-American Honorable Mention Coed Skipper: Connor Corgard
ICSA All-American Honorable Mention Coed Crew: Sara Swanson
2014-15
ICSA All-American Coed Skipper: Tyler Macdonald
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Breanne Baldino
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Abby Preston
2013-14
ICSA All-American Honorable Mention Coed Skipper: Tyler Macdonald
2012-13
ICSA All-American Coed Skipper: Alec Anderson
ICSA All-American Honorable Mention Coed Crew: Alyssa Siefert
2011-12
ICSA All-American Coed Skipper: Alec Anderson
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Sophie Bellacosa
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Kelly Stannard
ICSA All-American Honorable Mention Coed Crew: Sean Bouchard
2010-11
ICSA All-American Coed Skipper: Alec Anderson
ICSA All-American Coed Skipper: Cy Thompson
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Kelly Stannard
2009-10
ICSA All-American Coed Skipper: Cy Thompson
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Kelly Stannard
2008-09
ICSA All-American Coed Skipper: Matthew Duggan
ICSA All-American Coed Skipper: Cy Thompson
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Kaitlyn Hall
ICSA All-American Coed Crew: Maria Petrillo
2007-08
ICSA All-American Honorable Mention Coed Skipper: Matthew Duggan
ICSA All-American Honorable Mention Coed Skipper: Andrew Goetting
2006-07
ICSA All-American Honorable Mention Coed Skipper: David Hyer
WOMEN’S SOCCER
2015
NSCAA All-American First Team: Mariah Kaiser
2014
NSCAA All-American Third Team: Mariah Kaiser
MEN’S SOCCER
2022
United Soccer Coaches NCAA Division III All-America Third Team: Javi Beltran
2021
United Soccer Coaches NCAA Division III All-America Third Team: Javi Beltran
2013
NSCAA Division III All-American Second Team: Trevor Hoxsie
2012
NSCAA Division III All-American Second Team: Kamali Webson
2007
NSCAA Division III All-American Third Team: Antoine Bell
2005
NSCAA Division III All-American First Team: Kevin Deegan
2002
NSCAA Division III All-American Third Team: Andrew Combra
2000
NSCAA Division III All-American Second Team: Stuart Hulke
1998
NSCAA Division III All-American Third Team: Stuart Hulke
WOMEN’S SWIMMING & DIVING
2021-22
NCAA All-American Honorable Mention – 100 Yard Freestyle: Ellie Field
MEN’S SWIMMING & DIVING
2021-22
NCAA All-American Honorable Mention – 400 Yard Individual Medley: Riley Williams
WOMEN’S TRACK & FIELD
2026
NCAA Division III Women’s Track and Field All-American First Team: Angela West
2025
NCAA Division III Women’s Track and Field All-American Second Team: Angela West
MEN’S TRACK & FIELD
2026
NCAA Division III Men’s Track and Field All-American First Team (5000m): Nathan Tassey
NCAA Division III Men’s Track and Field All-American First Team(10000m): Nathan Tassey
NCAA Division III Men’s Track and Field All-American Second Team: Justin Dickson
2024
NCAA Division III Men’s Track and Field All-American First Team: Nathan Tassey
WOMEN’S VOLLEYBALL
2017
AVCA Division III All-American Honorable Mention: Molly Quilty
2014
AVCA Division III All-American Honorable Mention: Kristen Boyer, Elizabeth Flaherty, Brittany McMullen
2013
AVCA Division III All-American Third Team: Krystie Luczynski
AVCA Division III All-American Honorable Mention: Elizabeth Flaherty
2010
AVCA Division III All-American Third Team: Rebekah Dion
AVCA Division III All-American Honorable Mention: Jill Hurd
MEN’S VOLLEYBALL
2004
AVCA Division III All-American Second Team: Jack Delehanty
WRESTLING
2018-19
NCAA Division III All-American: Taylor Shay
2016-17
NCAA Division III All-American: Ty Herzog
2015-16
NCAA Division III All-American & 197 lbs. National Champion: David Welch
2013-14
NCAA Division III All-Americans: Collin Crowell, David Welch
2005-06
NCAA Division III All-American: Andy Lacroix
2002-03
NCAA Division III All-American: Cory DeBias
1999-00
NCAA Division III All-American: Pete Doucet
1994-95
NCAA Division III All-American: John LaScala
