| 2021 |
| All-CCC First Team: Chris Flynn, Danny Roth |
| All-CCC Second Team: Ben Bonavita, Tyler Cedeno, Justin Garcia, Brandon Jenkins, George Somers |
| All-CCC Third Team: Joey Gulino, Matt Massaro |
| CCC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Brandon Jenkins |
| NEIBA Division III All-Star: Brandon Jenkins |
| D3baseball.com All-New England Region Second Team: Brandon Jenkins |
| D3baseball.com All-New England Region Third Team: Danny Roth |
| ABCA/Rawlings New England All-Region First Team: Brandon Jenkins |
| ABCA/Rawlings New England All-Region Second Team: Justin Garcia, Danny Roth |
|
| 2019 |
| All-CCC First Team: Chris Bosco, Connor Hewlette, Danny Roth, Justin Stone |
| All-CCC Second Team: Eli Camner, Craig Demers |
| All-CCC Third Team: Anthony Dominguez, Justin Garcia, Joey Gulino |
| CCC Pitcher of the Year: Connor Hewlette |
| CCC Defensive Player of the Year: Chris Bosco |
| NCBWA Division III Rookie of the Week - Kyle Schaefer |
| D3baseball.com Team of the Week - Connor Hewlette |
| NEIBA All-Star Game Selection: Anthony Dominguez |
| NEIBA All-Region First Team: Danny Roth |
| NEIBA All-Region Third Team: Connor Hewlette |
| ABCA/Rawlings New England All-Region First Team: Danny Roth |
| ABCA/Rawlings New England All-Region Third Team: Connor Hewlette |
|
| 2018 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Sam Bennett, Chris Bosco |
| All-CCC Third Team: Justin Garcia, Shane Nowak, Matt Vernacatola |
|
| 2017 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Chris Bosco |
| All-CCC Third Team: Justin Stone |
| NEIBA All-Region Third Team: Chris Bosco |
| ABCA/Rawlings New England All-Region Third Team: Chris Bosco |
| NCAA Division III Statistical Leader (Runners Thrown Out): Chris Bosco |
|
| 2016 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Kevin Baker |
| All-CCC Third Team: Jamie Timothy |
|
| 2015 |
| All-CCC First Team: Troy DeLeon |
| All-CCC Second Team: Chris Travers, Tyler Campo |
| D3baseball.com Preseason Division III All-American: George Lund |
|
| 2014 |
| All-CCC First Team: George Lund, Reid Nelson, Jamie Timothy |
| All-CCC Second Team: Tyler Pogmore, Caulin Rogers |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Sean Boyle |
| CCC Senior Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Sean Boyle |
| CCC Co-Coach of the Year: Derek Carlson |
| NEIBA All-New England First Team: George Lund |
| NEIBA All-New England Second Team: Tyler Pogmore |
| NEIBA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Tyler Pogmore |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star First Team: George Lund |
| ABCA/Rawlings New England All-Region First Team: George Lund, Tyler Pogmore |
| ABCA/Rawlings New England All-Region Third Team: Jamie Timothy |
| D3baseball.com All-New England Region First Team: George Lund, Tyler Pogmore |
| D3baseball.com Preseason Division III All-American: Tyler Pogmore |
| D3baseball.com Division III All-America Second Team: Tyler Pogmore |
| D3baseball.com Division III All-America Honorable Mention: George Lund |
| ABCA Division III All-America Third Team: George Lund |
|
| 2013 |
| All-CCC Second Team: John Oppenhimer, Tyler Pogmore |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Sean Boyle, Matt Jefferis, Reid Nelson, Mike Pascarella |
| CCC Team Sporsmanship Award: Roger Williams University |
| NEIBA All-New England First Team: Tyler Pogmore |
|
| 2012 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Sean Boyle, John Oppenhimer |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Trevor Manzi |
|
| 2011 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Trevor Manzi, Josh Orosz |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: John Oppenhimer |
|
| 2009 |
| All-CCC First Team: Grant Bolin |
| All-CCC Second Team: Alex Perry |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Jamie Dahill, Brian Hurld |
| NEIBA All-New England Third Team: Brian Hurld |
|
| 2008 |
| All-CCC First Team: Brian Hurld, Kevin Simpson |
| All-CCC Second Team: Bill Lambert |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Jamie Dahill, James Lydon, Alex Perry, Tony Verrochi |
| CCC Pitcher of the Year: Brian Hurld |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Derek Carlson |
| Perfect Game (W 1-0 vs. Wentworth) - Dan Roberge |
| ECAC Division III New England Tournament Most Outstanding Player: Zach Porter |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star Second Team: Kevin Simpson |
|
| 2007 |
| All-CCC First Team: Bill Lambert |
| All-CCC Second Team: Jamie Dahill, James Lydon, Alex Perry, Kevin Simpson |
| NEIBA All-New England Third Team: Kevin Simpson, James Lydon |
|
| 2006 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Andrew Lippincott, Mike Malcolm, Kevin Thompson |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Derek Carlson |
| CoSIDA Academic All-District Team: Andrew Lippincott |
|
| 2005 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Travis Cooney |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Andy Lippincott |
|
| 2004 |
| All-CCC First Team: Brian Robinson |
|
| 2003 |
| All-CCC First Team: Brian Robinson |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Carl Melchar, Josh Rosen |
| NEIBA Division III All-New England Second Team: Brian Robinson |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star Second Team: Brian Robinson |
|
| 2002 |
| All-CCC First Team: Brian Robinson, Josh Rosen |
| All-CCC Second Team: Jason Harrington, Carl Melchar |
| CCC Pitcher of the Year: Josh Rosen |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star Second Team: Brian Robinson |
| Jewish Sports Review College Division Division III All-America First Team: Josh Rosen |
|
| 2001 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Steven Browne, Chris Sullivan |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Brian Robinson, Josh Rosen, Colin Whalen |
| CCC Senior Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Steven Browne |
|
| 2000 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Lenny Johnson |
|
| 1999 |
| All-CCC First Team: Chris Sullivan |
| All-CCC Second Team: Matt Killam, Tom Laverriere |
| CCC Pitcher of the Year: Matt Killam |
|
| 1998 |
| All-CCC First Team: Kevin LeClair, Chris Sullivan |
| All-CCC Second Team: Dana Altobello, Tom Laverriere |
| CCC Pitcher of the Year: Kevin LeClair |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Val Innocente |
|
| 1997 |
| All-CCC First Team: Dana Altobello |
| All-CCC Second Team: Nathan Craven, Walter Moquin |
|
| 1996 |
| All-CCC First Team: Chris Johnson |
| All-CCC Second Team: Chris Moorby |
| CCC Senior Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Chris Johnson |
| CoSIDA Division III Academic All-America Third Team: Chris Johnson |
|
| 1995 |
| All-CCC First Team: Chris Johnson |
| All-CCC Second Team: Keith Whitaker |
|
| 1994 |
| All-CCC First Team: Paul Gilmore |
| All-CCC Second Team: Mark Follo, Mike McNamara |
|
| 1993 |
| All-CCC First Team: Mike LeBrun |
| All-CCC Second Team: Mike McNamara |
|
| 1992 |
| All-CCC First Team: Mike LeBrun, Todd Rivard |
| All-CCC Second Team: Craig Babineau, Mark Follo |
|
| 1991 |
| All-CCC First Team: Mike Mousseau |
| All-CCC Second Team: Todd Rivard |
|
| 1989 |
| All-CCC: Kamal Asar, Mark Elliott, Todd Rivard |
|
| 1983 |
| All-Mayflower Conference: Peter Waters |
| All-NAIA District 5: Peter Waters |
|
| 1982 |
| All-Mayflower Conference: Peter Waters |
| All-NAIA District 5: Peter Waters |
|
| 1981 |
| All-Mayflower Conference: Peter Waters |
| All-NAIA District 5: Peter Waters |
|
