| 2024 |
| All-CCC First Team: Matt Hemmert, Kyle Zirn |
| All-CCC Second Team: Riley Spellman |
| All-CCC Third Team: Matt Halpin, Kevin Murphy, Tyler Zanini |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Riley Spellman |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selections: Kevin Murphy, Brian Gazard, Matt Halpin, Tyler Zanini |
| USILA Scholar All-Americans: Kevin Murphy, Matt Halpin, Matt Hemmert, Tyler Zanini |
| NEILA All-Academic Team: Kevin Murphy, Matt Halpin, Tyler Zanini |
|
| 2023 |
| All-CCC First Team: Matt Halpin |
| All-CCC Second Team: Kevin Murphy, Kyle Zirn |
| All-CCC Third Team: Jack Kester, Tyler Zanini, Michael Bussinelli |
|
| 2022 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Jared Grier, Hunter Goodrow, Max Kimmel |
| All-CCC Third Team: Tim Mullane, Tyler Zanini, Brian Cumming |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selections: Hunter Goodrow, Ryan Phillips, Jared Grier, Tim Mullane |
|
| 2021 |
| All-CCC First Team: Jared Grier, Connor Hillemeir, Peter Navarro |
| All-CCC Second Team: Tyler Zanini |
| All-CCC Third Team: Ryan Bannon, Hunter Goodrow, Tim Mullane, Brenden Whitten |
| CCC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Brenden Whitten |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selections: Jared Grier, Connor Hillemeir, Peter Navarro |
| NEILA All-Academic Team: Jared Grier, Tim Mullane, Peter Navarro, Brenden Whitten |
| USILA Division III Senior All-Star Game Selections: Andrew Gaffney, Peter Navarro |
| USILA Division III All-America Honorable Mention: Connor Hillemeir, Peter Navarro |
| USILA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Jared Grier, Peter Navarro |
|
| 2020 |
| USILA Division III Scholar All-American: Jude Marzec |
|
| 2019 |
| All-CCC First Team: Shawn Errasti, Jude Marzec |
| All-CCC Second Team: Chris Bova, Brian Brockwell |
| All-CCC Third Team: Connor Hillemeir, Peter Navarro, Brenden Whitten |
| NEILA Academic All-New England Team: Joseph Elia, Shawn Errasti |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Shawn Errasti |
| USILA Division III Scholar All-American: Shawn Errasti |
|
| 2018 |
| All-CCC First Team: Shawn Errasti |
| All-CCC Second Team: Justin MacIntyre, Peter Navarro |
| All-CCC Third Team: Brian Brockwell |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Justin MacIntyre |
| NEILA Academic All-New England Team: Justin MacIntyre |
|
| 2017 |
| All-CCC First Team: Shawn Errasti |
| All-CCC Second Team: Stephen Assumma, AJ Core, Eddie Hill |
| All-CCC Third Team: Jude Marzec, Drew Mullin |
| NEILA Academic All-New England Team: AJ Core |
|
| 2016 |
| All-CCC First Team: AJ Core, Cam Donnelly |
| All-CCC Second Team: Shawn Errasti, Nick Gagnon, Caleb Kenney, Jon Lazar |
| All-CCC Third Team: Eddie Hill, Will Siefert, Eric Valenti |
| CCC Senior Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Dan Arket |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selections: Cam Donnelly, Nick Gagnon |
| NEILA Academic All-New England: Dan Arket, Nick Gagnon, Caleb Kenney, Eric Valenti |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star Second Team: Nick Gagnon, Eric Valenti |
|
| 2015 |
| All-CCC First Team: Mark Fesenmeyer, Caleb Kenney |
| All-CCC Second Team: Luke Aubrey, Patrick Holland, Will Siefert |
| All-CCC Third Team: Dan Arket, Max Cammarota, Cam Donnelly, Jon Gomer, Tim Kelly |
| CCC Short-Stick Specialist of the Year: Caleb Kenney |
| CCC Senior Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Mark Fesenmeyer |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selections: Patrick Holland, Mark Fesenmeyer |
| NEILA All-New England Honorable Mention: Patrick Holland |
| NEILA Academic All-New England: Luke Aubrey, Mark Fesenmeyer |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star First Team: Mark Fesenmeyer |
| USILA Division III All-America Honorable Mention: Mark Fesenmeyer |
| USILA Division III Scholar All-American: Mark Fesenmeyer |
|
| 2014 |
| All-CCC First Team: Will Siefert, Alan Williams |
| All-CCC Second Team: Luke Aubrey, Patrick Connolly, Mark Fesenmeyer |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Garrett Ficara, Nick Gagnon, Mike Hanna, Jon Nessa, John Riccardi |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selections: John Ricciardi, Alan Williams |
| NEILA All-New England First Team: Will Siefert, Alan Williams |
| NEILA All-New England Honorable Mention: John Ricciardi |
| NEILA Senior Scholar Academic All-Region: Patrick Connolly, Alan Williams |
|
| 2013 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Patrick Holland, John Ricciardi, Alan Williams |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Luke Aubrey, Cam Donnelly, Mark Fesenmeyer, Will Siefert, Kirby Sundquist |
|
| 2012 |
| All-CCC First Team: Jon Nessa, Collin Schmitt |
| All-CCC Second Team: Drew Beck, Mitri Najjar |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Todd Carson, Mark Fesenmeyer, Patrick Holland, Cameron Signorelli, Alan Williams |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Luke Aubrey |
| ECAC Division III New England Co-Rookie of the Year: Luke Aubrey |
| USILA Division III Scholar All-American: Collin Schmitt |
|
| 2011 |
| All-CCC First Team: Drew Smith, Jim Turenne |
| All-CCC Second Team: Austin Fehringer, Logan Roebuck |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Tyler Roebuck |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selections: Logan Roebuck, Jim Turenne |
|
| 2010 |
| All-CCC First Team: Drew Smith |
| All-CCC Second Team: Rian Kearney, Logan Roebuck |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Glenn Pacitti, Tyler Roebuck |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Rian Kearney |
| NEILA All-New England Second Team: Jim Turenne |
|
| 2009 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Joe Healy, Mike Horan |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Sean Benner, Austin Fehringer, Mike Fox, Dave Hurley, Packy Markham, Chris Mecozzi, Glenn Pacitti |
|
| 2008 |
| All-CCC First Team: Joe Healy |
| All-CCC Second Team: Dave Hurley, Slade Patterson |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Beaver Barone, Chris Edwards, Mike Fox, Mike Horan, Rian Kearney |
|
| 2007 |
| All-CCC First Team: Joe Healy |
| All-CCC Second Team: Beaver Barone, Mike Fox, Michael Horan |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Bobby Hensley, Dave Hurley, Slade Patterson |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Marty Kelly |
|
| 2006 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Slade Patterson |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Beaver Barone |
|
| 2005 |
| All-CCC First Team: Ross Baker, Joel Cohen |
| All-CCC Second Team: Doug D'Auria |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Bobby Hensley, Tigger Knecht |
| CCC Senior Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Ross Baker |
| CCC Team Sporsmanship Award: Roger Williams University |
|
| 2004 |
| All-CCC First Team: Joel Cohen, Kenny Seitles |
| All-CCC Second Team: Ross Baker, Jamie McCoy, Adam Vickers |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Doug D'Auria |
|
| 2003 |
| All-CCC First Team: Sean Kelley, Jamie McCoy, Kenny Seitles |
| All-CCC Second Team: Doug D'Auria, Cory MacEachen |
| NEILA All-New England Second Team: Kenny Seitles |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star Second Team: Kenny Seitles |
|
| 2002 |
| All-CCC First Team: Jamie McCoy |
| All-CCC Second Team: CJ Annunciata, Pete Awn, Cory MacEachen, Kenny Seitles |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Seth Funt, Sean Kelley, Dave LeBlanc |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Marty Kelly |
| NEILA All-New England Second Team: Sean Kelley |
| NEILA All-New England Honorable Mention: Jamie McCoy |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Pete Awn |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star Honorable Mention: Jamie McCoy |
| NCAA Division III Statistical Leader (Save Pct.): Jamie McCoy |
|
| 2001 |
| All-CCC First Team: Sean Sternberg |
| All-CCC Second Team: Dave LeBlanc, Sean Kelley, Kenny Seitles |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selections: Joe Curran, Dave McMullen |
|
| 2000 |
| All-CCC First Team: Brendon Giblin, Peter Moran |
| All-CCC Second Team: Seth Funt, Sean Sternberg |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Brendon Giblin |
|
| 1999 |
| All-CCC First Team: Chris Cokas, Ben Redfield |
| All-CCC Second Team: Brendon Giblin, Peter Moran |
| CCC Senior Co-Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Chris Cokas |
|
| 1998 |
| All-CCC First Team: Chris Cokas, Evan Gould |
| All-CCC Second Team: Brendon Giblin, Ben Redfield |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Evan Gould |
| NEILA All-New England Honorable Mention: Evan Gould |
|
| 1997 |
| NEILA All-New England Honorable Mention: Ben Redfield |
|
| 1996 |
| All-Pilgrim League: Howard Brande |
|
| 1995 |
| All-Pilgrim League: Mike Breard, Warren Danzenbaker |
| Pilgrim League Player of the Year: Mike Breard |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selections: Mike Breard, Warren Danzenbaker |
| USILA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Mike Breard |
|
| 1994 |
| All-Pilgrim League: Rick Alderman, Mike Breard, Pat Cooney, Chad Meisner, Dave Wojdyl |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Chad Meisner |
| NEILA All-New England Second Team: Rick Alderman |
|
| 1993 |
| All-Pilgrim League: Rick Alderman, Mike Flanigan, Terry Kelly, Dave Wojdyl |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selections: Rick Alderman, Terry Kelly |
|
| 1992 |
| All-Pilgrim League: Jeremy Abraham, Rick Alderman, Patrick Cooney, Billy Curtis, Mark Hoey, Terry Kelly, Chad Meisner, Dave Wojdyl |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selections: Billy Curtis, Mark Hoey |
| USILA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Billy Curtis |
|
| 1991 |
| All-Pilgrim League: Rick Alderman, Mike Aliperti, Steve Gryzlo, Terry Kelly |
| NEILA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Mike Aliperti |
| USILA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Mike Aliperti |
|
| 1989 |
| All-Pilgrim League: Mike Aliperti, Steve Gryzlo |
|
|
