| 2024 |
| All-CCC Second Team:
Tyler Jastrab,
Jack Wildermann,
Dylan Thomas,
Jason Salley |
| All-CCC Third Team:
Brandon Rodriguez,
Hogan Cain |
|
Community Service Team:
Andre Caceres |
| CNE Rookie of the Year: Tyler Jastrab |
|
| 2023 |
| All-CCC First Team:
Jack Wildermann,
Niall Shea |
| All-CCC Second Team:
Liam Blaisdell,
CJ Sousa,
Jason Salley,
Hogan Cain |
| All-CCC Third Team:
Dylan Thomas |
| CCC Rookie of the Year:
Dylan Thomas |
|
| 2022 |
| All-CCC First Team: Justin Horvath, Javier Beltran, Niall Shea, Jack Avellar |
| All-CCC Third Team: Jack Wildermann, Jason Salley |
| CCC Offensive Player of the Year: Jack Avellar |
| CCC Fall All-Academic Team: Andre Caceres, Austin Hilger, Elias Choclin, Jack Wetzel, Justin Horvath, Matt Bagley, Nathan Silveira, Niall Shea, Tyler Andrade |
|
| 2021 |
| All-CCC First Team: Jack Avellar, Javi Beltran, Niall Shea |
| All-CCC Second Team: Tyler Andrade, Austin Hilger, Justin Horvath |
| All-CCC Third Team: Jack Wetzel |
| CCC Offensive Player of the Year: Javi Beltran |
| United Soccer Coaches All-Region II First Team: Javi Beltran |
| United Soccer Coaches All-Region II Third Team: Tyler Andrade |
| United Soccer Coaches NCAA Division III All-America Third Team: Javi Beltran |
|
| 2019 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Garrett Bolton, Edmund Geschictker |
| All-CCC Third Team: Tyler Andrade, Javi Beltran, Michael Oliveira |
|
| 2018 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Garrett Bolton, Edmund Geschictker, Ryan Miller, Stathi Panagiotidis |
|
| 2017 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Sean Janson, Charlie Mader |
| All-CCC Third Team: Edmund Geschickter |
|
| 2016 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Sean Janson, Charlie Mader |
| All-CCC Third Team: Edmund Geschickter |
|
| 2015 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Trevor Sparda |
| All-CCC Third Team: Sean Janson, Charlie Mader |
|
| 2014 |
| All-CCC First Team: Andrew Carlson |
| All-CCC Second Team: Trevor Sparda |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Cooper Allebrand, Kyle Farabaugh |
| NSCAA All-New England Third Team: Andrew Carlson |
|
| 2013 |
| All-CCC First Team: Trevor Hoxsie, Rich Pomeroy |
| All-CCC Second Team: Daniel Caruso, James Sheldon |
| CCC Co-Offensive Player of the Year: Trevor Hoxsie |
| NSCAA Scholar All-East Honorable Mention: Cooper Allebrand, Scott Boucher, Andre Brueckner |
| ECAC Division III New England Offensive Player of the Year: Trevor Hoxsie |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star Second Team: Rich Pomeroy |
| NSCAA All-New England Third Team: Trevor Hoxsie |
| NSCAA Division III All-America Second Team: Trevor Hoxsie |
|
| 2012 |
| All-CCC First Team: Andres Daza, Trevor Hoxsie, Kamali Webson |
| All-CCC Second Team: Paul Arute, Daniel Caruso, Billy Kissane, Jon Pelloso |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Bradley Macdonald |
| CCC Offensive Player of the Year: Trevor Hoxsie |
| CCC Defensive Player of the Year: Kamali Webson |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Jim Cook |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Andres Daza, Kamali Webson |
| NCAA All-New England South First Team: Trevor Hoxsie, Kamali Webson |
| NCAA All-New England South Second Team: Andres Daza |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star: Kamali Webson |
| NSCAA Scholar All-East Honorable Mention: Paul Arute, Scott Boucher, Jon Pelloso |
| NSCAA Division III All-America Second Team: Kamali Webson |
|
| 2011 |
| All-CCC First Team: Daniel Caruso, Trevor Hoxsie, Kamali Webson |
| All-CCC Second Team: Andres Daza |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Billy Kissane, Jon Pelloso |
| NSCAA All-New England First Team: Kamali Webson |
| NSCAA All-New England Second Team: Trevor Hoxsie |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star First Team: Kamali Webson |
| NSCAA Scholar All-East: Paul Arute, Josh Boyce |
|
| 2010 |
| All-CCC First Team: Kamali Webson |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Peter Plate |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Peter Plate |
|
| 2009 |
| All-CCC First Team: Justin Plourde |
| All-CCC Second Team: Liam Isleib, Peter Plate |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Andres Daza, Kevin Hand |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Justin Plourde |
| NSCAA All-New England First Team: Justin Plourde |
| NSCAA All-New England Second Team: Liam Isleib |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star First Team: Justin Plourde |
|
| 2008 |
| All-CCC First Team: Ardy Jagne, Dan Saccoccio |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Jared Falconer, Archie Maoh, Peter Plate, Justin Plourde |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Archie Maoh |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Dan Saccoccio |
| NCAA Division III Men All-New England Second Team: Dan Saccoccio |
| NSCAA Scholar All-East Region: Joey Summa |
|
| 2007 |
| All-CCC First Team: Antoine Bell, Ardy Jagne, Dan Saccoccio |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Brandon O'Donovan |
| CCC Player of the Year: Antoine Bell |
| NSCAA All-New England Team: Antoine Bell |
| D3Kicks.com New England First Team: Antoine Bell |
| NSCAA Scholar All-East: Joey Summa, Eván Solis |
| CoSIDA Academic All-District Team: Eván Solis |
| NSCAA Division III All-America Third Team: Antoine Bell |
|
| 2006 |
| All-CCC First Team: Antoine Bell, Brendan Cavanaugh, Kevin Deegan, Rich Reddington |
| All-CCC Second Team: Ardy Jagne |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Dan Saccoccio |
| CCC Player of the Year: Antoine Bell |
| CCC Senior Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Kevin Deegan |
| NCAA Division III Statistical Leader (Save Pct.): Kevin Deegan |
| NCAA Division III Statistical Leader (Goals-Against Avg.): Kevin Deegan |
|
| 2005 |
| All-CCC First Team: Michael Bray, Kevin Deegan, Patrick Milner, Jamie Pereira |
| All-CCC Second Team: Ardy Jagne |
| CCC Player of the Year: Kevin Deegan |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Ardy Jagne |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Jim Cook |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Patrick Milner |
| NSCAA Division III All-America First Team: Kevin Deegan |
| NSCAA Division III Scholar All-America First Team: Kevin Deegan |
|
| 2004 |
| All-CCC First Team: Nate Boucher, Brian Cussen, Kevin Deegan, Rich Reddington |
| All-CCC Second Team: Sean Whalen |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Patrick Milner |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Nate Boucher |
| NSCAA All-New England Second Team: Kevin Deegan, Rich Reddington |
|
| 2003 |
| All-CCC First Team: Andrew Combra, Jamie Danis, Kevin Deegan, Tony Nunes, Rich Reddington, James Trill |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Patrick Milner |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Kevin Deegan |
| ECAC Division III New England Tournament Most Valuable Player: Tony Nunes |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Tony Nunes |
| NSCAA All-New England First Team: Andrew Combra |
| NSCAA All-New England Second Team: Tony Nunes, Rich Reddington |
|
| 2002 |
| All-CCC First Team: Tim Amato, Andrew Combra, Tony Nunes, James Trill, Colin Whalen |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Josh Rosen |
| CCC Player of the Year: Andrew Combra |
| CCC Co-Coach of the Year: Jim Cook |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Tim Amato |
| CoSIDA Academic All-District First Team: Josh Rosen |
| NSCAA All-New England First Team: Andrew Combra |
| NSCAA All-New England Second Team: Colin Whalen |
| NSCAA All-New England Third Team: Tim Amato |
| NSCAA Division III All-America Third Team: Andrew Combra |
| Jewish Sports Review Division III All-America Team: Josh Rosen |
|
| 2001 |
| All-CCC First Team: Tim Amato, Andrew Combra, Chris Curran, Tony Nunes |
| All-CCC Second Team: David Hatch, Colin Whalen |
| CCC Player of the Year: Andrew Combra |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Chris Curran |
| NSCAA All-New England Second Team: Andrew Combra |
| NSCAA All-New England Third Team: Chris Curran |
| Jewish Sports Review Division III All-America Team: Josh Rosen, Neal Rosenthal |
|
| 2000 |
| All-CCC First Team: Chris Curran, Stuart Hulke, Brent Malo, Eric Rodgers, Greg Somerville |
| All-CCC Second Team: Timothy Amato, Adam Sweet |
| CCC Co-Player of the Year: Stuart Hulke |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Jim Cook |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Stuart Hulke |
| NSCAA All-New England First Team: Stuart Hulke |
| NSCAA All-New England Third Team: Chris Curran |
| NSCAA All-New England Fourth Team: Brent Malo, Eric Rodgers |
| NSCAA Division III All-America Second Team: Stuart Hulke |
|
| 1999 |
| All-CCC First Team: Stuart Hulke, Brent Malo, Matt Randall, Eric Rodgers |
| All-CCC Second Team: Chris Curran, Adam Sweet |
| CCC Player of the Year: Stuart Hulke |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Matt Randall |
| NSCAA All-New England Second Team: Stuart Hulke |
|
| 1998 |
| All-CCC: First Team: Stuart Hulke, Seth Matheson, Matt Randall, Matt Snow |
| All-CCC Second Team: Chris Curran, Adam Sweet |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Seth Matheson |
| CCC Player of the Year: Stuart Hulke |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Jim Cook |
| NSCAA All-New England First Team: Stuart Hulke |
| NSCAA Division III All-America Third Team: Stuart Hulke |
|
| 1997 |
| All-CCC First Team: Paul Alzapiedi |
| All-CCC Second Team: Joel Dickinson, Paul Vollaro |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Matt Snow |
| CCC Player of the Year: Paul Alzapiedi |
| CCC Senior Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Peter Ferrera |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Paul Alzapiedi |
| NSCAA All-New England Third Team: Paul Alzapiedi |
|
| 1996 |
| All-CCC First Team: Paul Alzapiedi |
| All-CCC Second Team: Jonathan Blyth, Paul Vollaro |
|
| 1995 |
| All-CCC First Team: Michael Rego, Paul Vollaro |
| All-CCC Second Team: Jim McKenna, Kevin Nusky |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Michael Rego |
|
| 1994 |
| All-CCC First Team: Paul Alzapiedi, Scott Flood |
| All-CCC Second Team: Brian Proto, Tom Roach, Paul Vollaro |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Paul Vollaro |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Scott Flood |
|
| 1993 |
| All-CCC First Team: Michael Rego |
| All-CCC Second Team: Tom Roach |
| NEISL Senior All-Star Game Selection: Michael Street |
|
| 1992 |
| All-CCC First Team: Lolo Gutierrez, Scott Rivoira |
| All-CCC Second Team: Tom Roach |
|
| 1991 |
| All-CCC First Team: Matt Carroll, Scott Rivoira, Craig Rogers |
| All-CCC Second Team: Damon Braider, John Donzella |
| CCC Player of the Year: Matt Carroll |
|
| 1990 |
| All-CCC First Team: Matt Carroll |
| All-CCC Second Team: John Donzella, Scott Rivoira |
|
| 1984 |
| All-Mayflower Conference: Michael Clinton |
| NAIA All-District: Michael Clinton |
|
| 1983 |
| All-Mayflower Conference: Michael Clinton |
|
| 1982 |
| All-Mayflower Conference: Michael Clinton |
|
