| 2021-22 |
| All-NEWA First Team: Kyle Kaiser |
| All-NEWA Second Team: Travis Arata |
| All-Northeast Region: Travis Arata, Ben Bariso, Addison Boisvert, Kyle Kaiser, Cole Shaughnessy, Peter Tringali |
| NCAA Championship Qualifiers: Travis Arata, Addison Boisvert, Kyle Kaiser |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Ben Bariso, Addison Boisvert, Jacob Cardozo, Ben Dubois, Ryan Grebe, Kyle Kaiser, Michael Forte, Cole Shaughnessy, Peter Tringali, Luke Wassel |
|
| 2020-21 |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Addison Boisvert, Jacob Cardozo, Ryan Grebe, Michael Mirmina, Cole Shaughnessy, Peter Tringali, Nick Wagner |
|
| 2019-20 |
| All-Northeast Region: Travis Arata, Addison Boisvert, Tyler Gazaway, Brett Leonard, Andy Lombard, Anthony Malfitano, Taylor Shay |
| All-NEWA Honorable Mention: Travis Arata, Addison Boisvert, Tyler Gazaway, Brett Leonard, Andy Lombard, Anthony Malfitano, Taylor Shay |
| All-NEWA Academic Team: Travis Arata, Ben Bariso, Jacob Cardozo, Tommy Flaherty, Ryan Grebe, Brett Leonard, Nathaniel Lindsay, Michael Mirmina, Taylor Shay, Peter Tringali, Jackson Wrobel |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Travis Arata, Ben Bariso, Jacob Cardozo, Tommy Flaherty, Ryan Grebe, Brett Leonard, Nathaniel Lindsay, Taylor Shay, Peter Tringali, Jackson Wrobel |
|
| 2018-19 |
| All-NEWA First Team: Tyler Gazaway, Taylor Shay |
| All-NEWA Honorable Mention: Ryan DeLoach, Chris Fuschetto, Kyle Kaiser, Jack Kelly, Brett Leonard, Adam Patsun |
| All-NEWA All-Rookie Team: Luke Bokina, Ryan DeLoach, Chris Fuschetto, Ryan Grebe, Kyle Kaiser, Jack Kelly |
| All-NEWA Academic Team: Seth Frohnheiser, Ryan Grebe, Brett Leonard, Andy Lombard, Taylor Shay, Sean Wieck |
| All-Northeast Region: Ryan DeLoach, Chris Fuschetto, Tyler Gazaway, Kyle Kaiser, Jack Kelly, Brett Leonard, Adam Patsun, Taylor Shay |
| NCAA Championship Qualifiers: Tyler Gazaway, Taylor Shay |
| NCAA Division III All-American: Taylor Shay |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-American: Taylor Shay |
|
| 2017-18 |
| All-NEWA Second Team: Tyler Gazaway, Taylor Shay |
| All-NEWA Honorable Mention: Nicholas Barbaria, Justin Cochran, Brett Leonard, Connor Humphries |
| All-NEWA All-Rookie Team: Tristan Haviland, Mike Fernandes |
| All-Northeast Region: Nicholas Barbaria, Tyler Gazaway, Connor Humphries, Brett Leonard, Taylor Shay |
| NCAA Championship Qualifiers: Nicholas Barbaria, Tyler Gazaway, Connor Humphries, Taylor Shay |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Nicholas Barbaria, Connor Humphries, Brett Leonard, Sean Wieck |
|
| 2016-17 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Joe Albina, Kyle Foster, Ty Herzog |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Justin Cochran, Tyler Gazaway, Jason Jacobi, Taylor Shay |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Nicholas Barbaria |
| All-NEWA First Team: Ty Herzog |
| All-NEWA Second Team: Kyle Foster, Alec Golner, Jason Jacobi |
| All-NEWA Honorable Mention: Joe Albina, Justin Cochran, Chris Francis, Tyler Gazaway, Taylor Shay |
| All-Northeast Region: Nicholas Barbaria, Kyle Foster, Tyler Gazaway, Alec Golner, Ty Herzog, Jason Jacobi |
| NCAA Championship Qualifier: Ty Herzog |
| NCAA Division III All-American: Ty Herzog |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Nicholas Barbaria, Kyle Foster, Ty Herzog, Carter Merecki |
|
| 2015-16 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Justin Cochran, Kyle Foster, Alec Golner, Dan Ressler, David Welch |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Nicholas Barbaria, Matthew Vieira |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Dan Roger |
| All-NEWA Wrestler of the Year: David Welch |
| All-NEWA First Team: Kyle Foster, Alec Golner, Dan Ressler, David Welch |
| All-NEWA Second Team: Joe Albina, Daniel Downes, Ty Herzog |
| All-NEWA Honorable Mention: Nicholas Barbaria, Justin Cochran, Jean-Luc Lemieux |
| All-NEWA All-Rookie Team: Jean-Luc Lemieux |
| All-Northeast Region: Justin Cochran, Daniel Downes, Kyle Foster, Alec Golner, Ty Herzog, Jean-Luc Lemieux, Dan Ressler, David Welch |
| NCAA Championship Qualifiers: Daniel Downes, Kyle Foster, Alec Golner, Ty Herzog, Dan Ressler, David Welch |
| NCAA Division III 197 lbs. National Champion: David Welch |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Chris Cornwell, Kyle Foster, Ty Herzog, Zachary Marcoulier, Dan Roger, Tom Sewell |
|
| 2014-15 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Joe Albina, Kyle Foster, Dan Ressler, David Welch |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Nicholas Barbaria, Thomas Carta, Justin Cochran |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Ty Herzog |
| All-NEWA Academic Team: Nicholas Barbaria, Chris Cornwell, Nicholas DePierro, Josh Devriendt, Colin Egan, Matt Fanikos, Kyle Foster, Ty Herzog, Pete Hilburn, Zachary Marcoulier, CJ Moyer |
| All-Northeast Region: Nicholas Barbaria, Francisco Colom, Daniel Downes, Kyle Foster, Ty Herzog, Dan Ressler, David Welch |
| NCAA Championship Qualifiers: Francisco Colom, Kyle Foster, Ty Herzog, Dan Ressler, David Welch |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Nicholas Barbaria, Ty Herzog, Zachary Marcoulier, Kyle Foster, Joshua Devriendt |
|
| 2013-14 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Collin Crowell, Anthony D’Anton, Daniel Downes, Ty Herzog, Daniel Ressler, Shane Parcel, David Welch |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Patrick Lacroix |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Kyle Foster |
| All-NEWA: Francisco Colom, Collin Crowell, Anthony D’Anton, Daniel Downes, Patrick Lacroix, Shane Parcel, Dan Ressler, David Welch |
| All-Northeast Region: Francisco Colom, Colin Crowell, Anthony D’Anton, Kyle Foster, Patrick Lacroix, Shane Parcel, David Welch |
| NCAA Championship Qualifiers: Collin Crowell, Shane Parcel, David Welch |
| NCAA Division III All-Americans: Collin Crowell, David Welch |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Francisco Colom, Chris Cornwell, Collin Crowell, Daniel Downes, Kyle Foster, Ty Herzog, Patrick Lacroix, Shane Parcel, Dante Porrazzo, Dan Ressler |
|
| 2012-13 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Collin Crowell, Philip Ernst, Shane Parcel |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: James Carroll, Francisco Colom, Anthony D’Anton, Dante Porrazzo |
| Pilgrim League Scholar-Athlete Team: Collin Crowell, Anthony D’Anton, Philip Ernst, Shane Parcel, Dante Porrazzo |
| All-NEWA: Anthony D’Anton, Collin Crowell, Shane Parcel |
| NCAA All-New England: Anthony D’Anton, Collin Crowell, Shane Parcel |
| NCAA Championship Qualifiers: Collin Crowell, Shane Parcel |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Collin Crowell, Michael Forlenza |
|
| 2011-12 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Kyle D’Urso, Philip Ernst, Shane Parcel |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Collin Crowell, Conor Hayes |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Michael Forlenza |
| All-NEWA: Collin Crowell, Kyle D’Urso, Philip Ernst, Conor Hayes, Shane Parcel |
| NCAA Championship Qualifier: Collin Crowell |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Philip Ernst, Kyle D’Urso, Shane Parcel |
|
| 2010-11 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Nick Cambi |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Phil Ernst, Michael Monson |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Collin Crowell |
| All-NEWA: Nick Cambi, Collin Crowell, Phil Ernst, Bobby Markowski, Michael Monson, Shane Parcel |
| NEWA Co-Rookie of the Year: Collin Crowell |
| NCAA Championship Qualifier: Nick Cambi |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Nick Cambi, Kyle D’Urso, Philip Ernst |
|
| 2009-10 |
| Pilgrim League First Team: Nick Cambi |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Philip Ernst, Jeremiah Mahoney, Kyle Rodgers |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Chris Nadeau |
| All-NEWA: Nick Cambi, Philip Ernst, Kyle Rodgers |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Nick Cambi, Kevin Edward |
|
| 2008-09 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Kyle Rodgers |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Andrew Hawley, Nicholas Herrick, Phil Kelly, Michael Trayser, Dan Woods, James Woods |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Chris Nadeau |
| All-NEWA: Andrew Hawley, Phil Kelly, Michael Trayser, Dan Woods, James Woods |
| NWCA Scholar All-Americans: Kenny Ford, Andrew Hawley, Chris Nadeau, Michael Trayser |
|
| 2007-08 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Kyle Rodgers, Dan Woods |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Jay Mahoney, Andrew Hawley, Kenny Ford, Jared Czarneski |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: James Woods |
| All-NEWA: Jared Czarneski, Andrew Hawley, Kyle Rodgers, John Russo, Dan Woods |
| NCAA Championship Qualifier: Jared Czarneski |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Kenny Ford, Chris Nadeau, Andrew Hawley |
|
| 2006-07 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Jared Czarneski, CJ McCormack, Scott Pellerin, John Russo |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Andy Lacroix |
| NECCWA All-New England: Jared Czarneski, Andy Lacroix, Scott Pellerin, Dan Woods, James Woods |
| NCAA Championship Qualifier: Andy Lacroix |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-American: Kenny Ford |
|
| 2005-06 |
| Pilgrim League First Team: Andy Lacroix, Dan Rokas, John Russo, Zach Weinrich |
| Pilgrim League Second Team: Anthony Nicolicchia, Michael Staples, Trevor Vernon |
| Pilgrim League Honorable Mention: Dan Woods |
| NECCWA All-New England: Andy Lacroix, CJ McCormack, Anthony Nicolicchia, Dan Rokas, John Russo, Mike Staples |
| NCAA Championship Qualifiers: Andy Lacroix, Anthony Nicolicchia, Zach Weinrich |
| NCAA Division III All-American: Andy Lacroix |
|
| 2004-05 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Scott Pellerin |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Andy Lacroix, Anthony Nicolicchia, Brian Young |
| NECCWA All New-England: Jon Egan, Andy Lacroix, Anthony Nicolicchia, Scott Pellerin |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Jon Egan, CJ McCormack, Scott Pellerin, Trevor Vernon |
|
| 2003-04 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Jon Egan, Joe Fitzsimons |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Joe Daigneault, Camilo Gaviria |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Brian Young |
| NECCWA All-New England: Jon Egan, Joe Fitzsimons, Camilo Gaviria |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Jon Egan, Joe Fitzsimons |
|
| 2002-03 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Cory DeBias, Joe Fitzsimons |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Jon Egan |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Scott Pellerin |
| NECCWA All-New England: Cory DeBias, Jon Egan, Joe Fitzsimons, Scott Pellerin |
| NCAA Championship Qualifiers: Cory DeBias, Joe Fitzsimons |
| NCAA Division III All-American: Cory DeBias |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Matt Boissonneault, Jon Egan, Joe Fitzsimons, Scott Pellerin |
|
| 2001-02 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Jeff Bernard, Joe Fitzsimons |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Jon Egan |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Brian Bagdon |
| NECCWA All-New England: Brian Bagdon, Jeff Bernard, Jon Egan, Joe Fitzsimons |
| CoSIDA Academic All-District Second Team: Jeff Bernard |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-American: Jeff Bernard |
|
| 2000-01 |
| Pilgrim League All-Star First Team: Brian Bagdon, Joe Curran, Kyle DeBias, Kevin Logue |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Second Team: Pete Doucet, Joe Fitzsimons |
| Pilgrim League All-Star Honorable Mention: Jesse Aquino |
| NECCWA All-New England: Brian Bagdon, Joe Curran, Kyle DeBias, Pete Doucet, Joe Fitzsimons, Kevin Logue |
| NCAA Championship Qualifier: Pete Doucet |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-American: Brian Bagdon |
|
| 1999-00 |
| Pilgrim League All-Stars: Brian Bagdon, Pete Doucet, Tim Grady, Kevin Logue |
| NECCWA All-New England: Brian Bagdon, Jeff Bernard, Pete Doucet, Kevin Logue |
| NCAA Championship Qualifier: Pete Doucet |
| NCAA Division III All-American: Pete Doucet |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-American: Jeff Bernard |
|
| 1998-99 |
| Pilgrim League All-Stars: Brian Bagdon, Angelo Diaz, Tim Grady, Keith Medeiros, J.D. Mislak, Ray Rask |
| NECCWA All-New England: Angelo Diaz, J.D. Mislak |
|
| 1997-98 |
| Pilgrim League All-Stars: Angelo Diaz, Dan Davis, Pete Doucet, Tim Grady, Keith Medeiros |
| NECCWA All-New England: Pete Doucet. Keith Medeiros, Jared Rolph |
| NCAA Championship Qualifier: Keith Medeiros |
|
| 1996-97 |
| Pilgrim League All-Stars: Pete Doucet, Keith Medeiros, Jeff Palmer |
| NECCWA All-New England: Angelo Diaz, Pete Doucet, Keith Medeiros, Kevin Neville |
| NCAA Championship Qualifiers: Keith Medeiros, Kevin Neville |
|
| 1995-96 |
| Pilgrim League All-Stars: Angelo Diaz, Spencer McCombe, Kevin Neville, Jason Rush |
| NECCWA All-New England: Angelo Diaz, Spencer McCombe, Jason Rush |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-American: Spencer McCombe |
|
| 1994-95 |
| Pilgrim League All-Stars: John LaScala, Dan Martin, Spencer McCombe, Keith Medeiros |
| NECCWA All-New England: John LaScala, Dan Martin, Spencer McCombe, Keith Medeiros, Jamie Procter |
| Amateur Wrestling News All-Rookie Team (All NCAA Divisions): John LaScala |
| NCAA Championship Qualifier: John LaScala |
| NCAA Division III All-American: John LaScala |
| NWCA Division III Scholar All-American: Spencer McCombe |
|
| 1993-94 |
| NECCWA All-New England: Jay Pelletier |
|
| 1992-93 |
| NECCWA All-New England: Spencer McCombe |
|
