| 2022 |
| All-CCC First Team: Ryleigh Cavanaugh, Nikki Norton, Mandy Beck, Madi Drain, Hannah Goodwin |
| All-CCC Second Team: Devon Sarazin, Lily Cunningham, Kimmy Creegan, Brooke McErlain |
| CCC Offensive Player of the Year: Mandy Beck |
|
| 2021 |
| All-CCC First Team: Ryleigh Cavanaugh, Madi Drain, Lauren Flahive, Devon Sarazin, Kate Shultz |
| All-CCC Second Team: Lily Cunningham |
| All-CCC Third Team: Brooke McErlain |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Ryleigh Cavanaugh |
| CCC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Isabella Blessington |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Jennifer Fox |
| IWLCA Academic Honor Roll: Delana Erickson, Lauren Flahive, Charlotte Perry, Devon Sarazin |
| IWLCA All-Pilgrim Region First Team: Lauren Flahive |
| IWLCA All-America Second Team: Lauren Flahive |
|
| 2019 |
| All-CCC First Team: Madi Drain, Emily Stoeppel |
| All-CCC Second Team: Rylie Dalzell, Lauren Flahive, Lydia Nelson, Ashley Warren |
| All-CCC Third Team: Devon Sarazin |
| CCC Co-Coach of the Year: Jennifer Fox |
| IWLCA All-Pilgrim Region Second Team: Emily Stoeppel |
| IWLCA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Emily Stoeppel |
|
| 2018 |
| All-CCC First Team: Lauren Flahive, Kaelin Hogan, Emily Stoeppel |
| All-CCC Second Team: Serena Murphy, Lydia Nelson, Devon Sarazin |
| All-CCC Third Team: Nicole Palombo |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Jennifer Fox |
| CCC Offensive Player of the Year: Kaelin Hogan |
| CCC Defensive Player of the Year: Emily Stoeppel |
| IWLCA All-Pilgrim Region Second Team: Kaelin Hogan, Emily Stoeppel |
| IWLCA Senior All-Star Game Selection: Kaelin Hogan |
|
| 2017 |
| All-CCC First Team: McKenna Everding, Kaelin Hogan, Caitlin Shanahan, Emily Stoeppel |
| All-CCC Second Team: Elizabeth Cahn, Kimberly Bolk |
| All-CCC Third Team: Alayna Fogg, Marin Owens |
| CCC Offensive Player of the Year: Kaelin Hogan |
| IWLCA All-Pilgrim Region Second Team: Kimberly Bolk, Kaelin Hogan |
|
| 2016 |
| All-CCC First Team: Kimberly Bolk, McKenna Everding, Kaelin Hogan, Caitlin Shanahan, Emily Stoeppel |
| All-CCC Second Team: Paige Byrne, Elizabeth Cahn, Caitlin Murphy |
| All-CCC Third Team: Serena Murphy |
| CCC Offensive Player of the Year: McKenna Everding |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Emily Stoeppel |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Lisa Vogeley |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star First Team: Kaelin Hogan |
| IWLCA All-Pilgrim Region Second Team: McKenna Everding |
|
| 2015 |
| All-CCC First Team: Deven Machette, Kelsey Rahilly, Caitlin Shanahan |
| All-CCC Second Team: Elizabeth Cahn, McKenna Everding, Mackenzie Logan |
| All-CCC Third Team: Kimberly Bolk, Kaelin Hogan |
| CCC Rookie of the Year: Kaelin Hogan |
| IWLCA Division III Academic Honor Roll: Mackenzie Logan, Kelsey Rahilly |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star Second Team: Deven Machette |
| IWLCA All-Pilgrim Region First Team: Kelsey Rahilly |
| IWLCA All-Pilgrim Region Second Team Deven Machette |
|
| 2014 |
| All-CCC First Team: Kelsey Rahily |
| All-CCC Second Team: Mackenzie Logan |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Deven Machette, Caitlin Murphy, Kristen Pingree |
| ECAC Division III New England All-Star First Team: Kelsey Rahily |
| IWLCA Division III Academic Honor Roll: Mackenzie Logan, Kristin Pingree, Kelsey Rahilly |
|
| 2013 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Mackenzie Logan |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Deven Machette, Kelsey Rahilly, Jessica Searl |
|
| 2012 |
| All-CCC First Team: Danica Delia |
| All-CCC Second Team: Mackenzie Logan |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Catherine Smeykal |
|
| 2011 |
| All-CCC First Team: Kelsey Adams, Danica Delia, Claire Halliday |
| All-CCC Second Team: Kate Malenczak, Nicole Papasergiou |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Erica Palmer, Justine Sullivan |
| IWLCA All-Pilgrim Region Second Team: Danica Delia, Claire Halliday |
|
| 2010 |
| All-CCC First Team: Claire Halliday, Amanda Magee, Nicole Papasergiou |
| All-CCC Second Team: Kasey Beckwith |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Jessie Alden |
| CCC Senior Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Jessie Alden |
| IWLCA All-Pilgrim Region Second Team: Amanda Magee, Nicole Papasergiou |
| NCAA Division III Statistical Leader (Save Pct.): Amanda Magee |
|
| 2009 |
| All-CCC First Team: Jackie Criss, Amanda Magee |
| All-CCC Second Team: Nicole Papasergiou, Emily Schall |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Kasey Beckwith, Shayna Beckwith, Claire Halliday |
| CCC Defensive Player of the Year: Jackie Criss |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Selina Collier |
|
| 2008 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Amanda Magee, Claire Halliday, Emily Schall |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Jackie Criss, Libby Stout |
| CCC Co-Coach of the Year: Emily Kiablick |
|
| 2007 |
| All-CCC First Team: Emily Schall, Kara Smolca |
| All-CCC Second Team: Jackie Criss, Amanda Magee |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Kary Rodgers |
| CCC Team Sporsmanship Award: Roger Williams University |
|
| 2006 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Jackie Criss, Kara Smolca |
| All-CCC Honorable Mention: Kary Rodgers |
| CCC Coach of the Year: Emily Kiablick |
|
| 2005 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Julia Smith, Kara Smolca |
|
| 2004 |
| All-CCC Second Team: Jen Dowd |
| CCC Team Sportsmanship Award: Roger Williams University |
